Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator

Compare a lump-sum pension buyout to lifetime monthly annuity payments.

  • Formula checked
  • Editorially reviewed
  • Free · no signup
  • Updated June 27, 2026

Your details

USD
USD
%

Your projected growth

Lump sum offer$400,000.00

Present value of annuity

$337,480.60

25 yrs @ 6%

Annuity advantage

$62,519.40

Lump sum is better by this amount

Break-Even return6.6%

Key takeaway

Lump sum option wins by $62,519.40 in present-value terms.

Saved on this device. No account required.

Share

Shares the calculator link. Your inputs stay on your device.

More ways to share

Privacy-safe: amounts you typed are never attached to a share link.

My dashboard

Saved on this device only — no account needed, no financial values leave your browser.

Growth over time

The same numbers as above, shown visually so the trade-offs are easy to see.

Growth over time
Present value of annuity
$337,480.60
Annuity advantage
$62,519.40
Projected balance over time

Year-by-year projection

Year-by-year projection for Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator. Assumes a constant annual return, contributions made at the end of each month, and no taxes or fees.
PeriodOpening balanceAddedGrowthClosing balance
Year 1$0$26,400$738$27,138
Year 2$27,138$26,400$2,412$55,950
Year 3$55,950$26,400$4,189$86,539
Year 4$86,539$26,400$6,076$119,015
Year 5$119,015$26,400$8,079$153,494
Year 6$153,494$26,400$10,205$190,099
Year 7$190,099$26,400$12,463$228,963
Year 8$228,963$26,400$14,860$270,223
Year 9$270,223$26,400$17,405$314,028
Year 10$314,028$26,400$20,107$360,535

Assumes a constant annual return, contributions made at the end of each month, and no taxes or fees.

What to do next

Break-Even Return6.6%Excellent

Pays for itself inside a year.

Benchmark: A refinance or points purchase only pays off if you hold past the break-even month.CFPB mortgage shopping guidance

What this means

Break-even lands at 6.6%. Before that point the upfront cost has not been recovered.

Is this good or bad?

Yes — this is a strong result by U.S. standards. Pays for itself inside a year.

What's the risk?

Low risk. Nothing here needs urgent attention — protect the position you are in.

What should you do next?

Compare to how long you'll stay

Your action plan

  1. 1

    Compare to how long you'll stay

    If you may move first, the upfront cost is a loss.

  2. 2

    Ask for a no-cost option

    A slightly higher rate with no fees can beat paying costs upfront.

  3. 3

    Confirm all fees are included

    Title, escrow and origination all belong in the break-even math.

  4. 4

    Re-run if rates move 0.25%

    Break-even is very sensitive to the rate spread.

  5. 5

    Run the Compound Interest Calculator

    How money grows with compounding over time.

    Open Compound Interest Calculator

Your timeline

Today

  • Confirm your current contribution percentage.
  • Note today's balance so you can measure progress.

This month

  • Increase contributions by 1%.
  • Verify your asset allocation matches your horizon.

Next 12 months

  • Top up to the annual IRS contribution limit.
  • Rebalance back to target allocation once.

Long term

  • Escalate contributions with every raise.
  • Shift toward lower volatility as the goal date approaches.
How you compare to U.S. benchmarks
MetricYour resultTypical U.S. rangeSource
Break-Even Return6.6%Under 36 monthsCFPB mortgage shopping guidance

Compare scenarios

Same inputs, three outlooks — we vary Expected investment return up and down so you can see the range before you commit.

Optimistic

$302,190.12

Present Value of Annuity

Expected investment return: 7.2%

Expected

$337,480.60

Present Value of Annuity

Expected investment return: 6%

Conservative

$379,654.52

Present Value of Annuity

Expected investment return: 4.8%

Result Intelligence

Understand your result

  • Your present value of annuity is $337,480.60. Long-horizon results are dominated by contributions early and returns later.
  • Assumed returns are historical averages — actual returns vary year to year.

What should you do next?

  1. Compound Interest Calculator

    Model long-term growth of contributions.

  2. Retirement Calculator

    Check if you're on track for retirement.

  3. Inflation Calculator

    See real purchasing power over time.

  4. Roth Conversion Calculator

    Weigh converting Traditional → Roth this year.

Ways to improve your result

  • Max the employer 401(k) match first — it's a 100% return.
  • Automate contributions on payday to remove behavior risk.
  • Rebalance annually; sell winners back to target, not on emotion.

Common U.S. scenarios

Chicago mid-career

$25k IRA balance at 35 → ~$220k at 65 at a 7% real return with $500/month added.

Seattle high earner

Backdoor Roth is the go-to for filers above the $161k (single) direct Roth income cap in 2025.

Florida retiree

RMDs start at age 73. A partial Roth conversion in early 60s can shrink future RMDs.

Your result

Present Value of Annuity
$337,480.60
Lump Sum Offer
$400,000.00
Annuity Advantage
$62,519.40
Break-Even Return
6.6%

Lump sum option wins by $62,519.40 in present-value terms.

What this result assumes

Confidence in a number depends on the assumptions behind it. Here are ours, in full.

Assumptions

  • The rate you entered stays fixed for the whole period.
  • Every period is a whole calendar period of equal length.
  • Payments and contributions are made on schedule, with none missed.
  • Returns are shown before taxes, fees and inflation unless an input covers them.
  • All amounts are shown in USD.

Limitations

Markets are not linear — a constant return is a planning device, not a forecast.

Estimates are for education and planning. They are not financial, tax or legal advice.

Formula source

SEC investor.gov compound-growth conventions

Version
v1.3
Last reviewed

Where to go next

Next logical calculatorCompound Interest CalculatorHow money grows with compounding over time.Continue

Read before you decide

Guides and comparisons that put this number in context.

Quick answer

What it does
Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator compare a lump-sum pension buyout to lifetime monthly annuity payments. It runs entirely in your browser, needs no signup, and uses standard published U.S. formulas.
When to use
Use it when you project growth, contributions, or returns tied to pension lump sum vs annuity.
Inputs
  • Lump sum offer
  • Monthly annuity option
  • Expected years in retirement
  • Expected investment return
  • Currency
Outputs
  • Lump Sum Offer
  • Present Value of Annuity
  • Annuity Advantage
  • Break-Even Return
Takeaway
In one line: enter your lump sum offer and monthly annuity option and the Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator returns lump sum offer and present value of annuity you can compare before deciding.

Last updated · 1 min read

How to read your result

Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator: Your result projects future value under the return, contribution, and horizon you chose. Markets vary year-to-year, so treat it as a planning range, not a promise.

What your result means

  • Compound growth means the last decade of your horizon does the heaviest lifting — start early.
  • A 1% higher return assumption can double the projected value over 30+ years — be conservative.
  • Inflation-adjusted (real) return is what actually determines your future purchasing power.

How does the formula work?

PV(annuity) = PMT × (1 − (1+r)^−n) / r. Compare to lump sum offer.

How it works

Employers often offer a choice between taking your pension as a one-time lump sum or a lifetime monthly annuity. The lump sum wins if you can beat the plan's implied return (usually 4–6%) and want inheritance flexibility. The annuity wins if you value longevity insurance and don't want to manage investments.

Step-by-step guide

  1. 1Enter the amount you plan to invest (one-time or monthly).
  2. 2Set the expected annual return and investment horizon.
  3. 3Adjust contributions, step-up, and inflation assumptions.
  4. 4Review projected value, gains, and year-by-year growth.
  5. 5Save or share the projection for your financial plan.

Example calculation

Example: $400k vs $2,200/mo for 25 years.

Who should use this calculator?

  • DIY investors planning long-term growth
  • Anyone starting a SIP or 401(k)/IRA contribution
  • Retirees estimating a safe withdrawal rate
  • Advisors modelling portfolio projections

When should you use it?

  • When starting a new SIP, 401(k) or IRA
  • During annual portfolio reviews
  • Before rebalancing or increasing contributions
  • When planning a retirement date

What affects the result?

  • Expected annual return and volatility
  • Contribution amount and frequency
  • Time horizon and start age
  • Inflation, taxes and fees
  • Employer match (for 401(k))

Compare three scenarios

Three realistic scenarios compared side by side
ScenarioInputsOutcome
Start at 25$400/mo, 7% return, 40 yrs≈ $1.05M — $192k contributed
Start at 35$400/mo, 7% return, 30 yrs≈ $488k — $144k contributed
Start at 45$400/mo, 7% return, 20 yrs≈ $208k — $96k contributed

Illustrative examples using U.S. market averages. Enter your own numbers above for a personalized figure.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Assuming a fixed rate of return every year.
  • Ignoring inflation when projecting future value.
  • Not accounting for taxes on gains or distributions.

Pro tips

  • Increase your contribution rate with each raise — even 1% compounds meaningfully.
  • Stress-test your plan with a lower return assumption to see the downside.
  • Always max the employer match before adding to a taxable account.

Why use this calculator

  • Long-horizon projections with realistic inflation and fee drag.
  • Compare lump-sum vs SIP vs step-up strategies instantly.
  • Employer match, tax bracket and Roth vs Traditional scenarios built in.
  • Year-by-year growth table you can export or share.

Limitations to keep in mind

  • Returns are assumptions, not guarantees — actual results will vary.
  • Ignores sequence-of-returns risk unless you model it explicitly.
  • Tax treatment depends on your jurisdiction and account type.
  • Not personalized investment advice — consult a fiduciary before acting.

Key terms explained

CAGR
Compound Annual Growth Rate — the smoothed yearly return that would take you from your starting value to your ending value over the period.
Real vs nominal return
Nominal return ignores inflation; real return subtracts it. Only real return reflects future purchasing power.
Dollar-cost averaging
Investing a fixed amount on a regular schedule. Reduces timing risk and smooths out entry prices over long horizons.
Expense ratio
The annual fee a fund charges as a % of assets. Even 0.5% higher fees can cost tens of thousands over 30 years.
Safe withdrawal rate
The % of a retirement portfolio you can withdraw yearly without running out — the classic 4% rule is a starting point, not a guarantee.

Before you decide

  • Confirm the account type (Roth, Traditional, taxable) matches your tax strategy.
  • Capture the full employer match before contributing anywhere else.
  • Stress-test the plan at a 2% lower return and higher inflation before relying on it.
  • Set an automatic contribution and an annual step-up on your raise date.

Official Sources & References

The formulas, rates and definitions used by this calculator are aligned with the following official sources:

We use only primary sources — regulators, standards bodies and scheme operators. See our full sourcing policy for details. Sources & References Policy · Calculator Methodology · How We Verify Formulas

Trust & Accuracy

Accuracy tested

Verified against SEC / AMFI compound-growth and XIRR conventions. Edge cases, formula validation and manual verification completed (last reviewed June 27, 2026).

Government source

Inputs and thresholds follow U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investor guidance.

Educational use

This tool is provided for education and planning only. It is not financial, tax, legal or medical advice.

Available for

United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Australia, India, European Union.

Currency support

USD · INR · CAD · AUD · GBP · EUR

Privacy

No information entered into this calculator is stored on our servers unless you explicitly choose to save or share your calculation.

Print, share & save

Use the Save, Share, Copy, PDF, CSV and Print actions under the result panel.

Accessibility

Keyboard navigable, screen-reader friendly labels, responsive on mobile and desktop.

Learn more: How we verify formulas · How we test accuracy · Methodology · Editorial policy

Recent Updates

We continuously review and improve our calculators to keep formulas, assumptions and references accurate.

View change log (4)Show
  1. v1.3

    Added Trust & Accuracy panel and machine-readable change log.

  2. v1.2

    Added Save, Share, PDF, CSV and Print actions to results.

  3. v1.1

    Added global currency selector (USD, INR, CAD, AUD, GBP, EUR).

  4. v1.0

    Initial calculator release with verified formulas and Official Sources.

Share this Calculator

Share to any platform, embed it on your site, or scan the QR code. No sign-up required.

More ways to share
Embed code

Frequently Asked Questions

Related guides

In-depth investment guides, worked examples, and expert explainers.

Related topics

What's next?

Your next step

Most people who use this calculator explore these next. Follow the path in order for a complete plan.

  1. 1Compound Interest CalculatorHow money grows with compounding over time.
  2. 2SIP CalculatorFuture value of monthly SIP investments.
  3. 3CAGR CalculatorCompound annual growth rate of an investment.

Recently updated

Beginner calculators

Simple, popular tools most people start with.

Advanced calculators

Specialised tools for deeper analysis.

Reviewed by the CreditLoanCalculator editorial team·Last reviewed ·Editorial policy·How we verify formulas
Disclaimer: Results are estimates for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial, medical, legal, or professional advice. Always consult a qualified professional before making decisions.