Decision Center

Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA Calculator

Pay taxes now or pay them later.

Traditional IRAs give you a deduction today and tax the withdrawal later. Roth IRAs skip the deduction but let the growth come out tax-free.

Option A

Roth IRA Calculator

Projects tax-free growth on after-tax contributions.

Pros

  • Tax-free withdrawals in retirement
  • No RMDs during your lifetime
  • Contributions can be withdrawn anytime

Cons

  • No upfront deduction
  • Income limits apply

Best for

Young earnersLow current tax bracketLong horizons

Typical user: Someone expecting a higher tax rate in retirement than today.

Open Roth IRA Calculator
Option B

Traditional IRA Calculator

Projects pre-tax growth with taxes owed on withdrawal.

Pros

  • Immediate tax deduction
  • Lowers current AGI
  • No income cap on contributions

Cons

  • RMDs start at 73
  • Withdrawals fully taxed as income

Best for

High earners todayPeak-earning yearsThose expecting a lower bracket later

Typical user: Someone in a higher tax bracket now than they'll be in retirement.

Open Traditional IRA Calculator

The verdict

Expect higher taxes later? Choose Roth. Higher taxes now? Traditional wins. If unsure, split contributions.

Related calculators