Decision Center

HELOC vs Home Equity Loan

Line of credit vs lump sum against your home.

A HELOC gives you a revolving credit line with variable rates. A home equity loan gives you a lump sum with a fixed rate — like a second mortgage.

Option A

HELOC Comparison

Compares a variable-rate line of credit against a fixed-rate equity loan.

Pros

  • Draw only what you need
  • Interest-only draw period option
  • Reusable credit line

Cons

  • Variable APR
  • Payment shock at repayment
  • Home is collateral

Best for

Ongoing renovationsEmergency reservesTuition over years

Typical user: Homeowner with irregular funding needs over time.

Open HELOC Comparison
Option B

Fixed Equity (Second Mortgage)

One-time lump sum, fixed payment, predictable amortization.

Pros

  • Fixed rate & payment
  • Simple budgeting
  • Great for one big project

Cons

  • Take the whole loan upfront
  • Interest starts day one

Best for

Single large projectDebt consolidationPredictable budgets

Typical user: Homeowner with one known, one-time expense.

Open Fixed Equity (Second Mortgage)

The verdict

Uncertain, ongoing costs → HELOC. One-time known amount → fixed home equity loan.

Related calculators